[Extension] - Weapon Handling - Versatile and Offhand attack

[Moon Wizard]

I believe this extension does more in terms of "enforcing" values on the type/hands fields; which I do not do in the built-in code by design.

Regards,
JPG

[Speculi]

The following was added to base 5E ruleset today:

* Ability to specify which hand(s) a PC weapon is used in (Primary, Two Hands, Off-Hand)
* Ability to specify Two Weapon Fighting Style in weapon section details
* Support for Versatile and Off-Hand damage calculations, based on the options above.

Regards,
JPG

Not sure where this should be reported, but since you already answered above:
Didn't do a comprehensive test, but it seems to me like offhand doesn't work as intended. It seems like only ranged weapons and versatile weapons can be properly set to "offhand". All others keep the damage bonus. (Tried with dagger and scimitar.)

Yes, the extension did more in enforcing the rules. The extension did actually check if the weapon was versatile, or light (unless you had the dual wielding feat) before it allowed to use it in offhand/two handed.

[Temmpest]

Oh boy. Almost deleted the extension.

[Moon Wizard]

Looks like it's working to me (see video). And enforcement is not done by design.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1MTK...ew?usp=sharing

Regards,
JPG

[mattekure]

It appears to work for me.

In the top pic, two weapon fighting style is not selected, and the offhand weapon does not include stat bonus for damage. In the bottom one two weapon style is selected, and the damage includes the stat bonus.

[delgondahntelius]

Looks like it's working to me (see video). And enforcement is not done by design.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1MTK...ew?usp=sharing

Regards,
JPG

In the video, when you switch the battle axe to Two Hands, it looks as if the damage goes from 2d8+3 to 1d10+1d8+3 ... is there something about battle axes I am missing? don't they do 1d8 1 handed and 1d10 two handed? Or is there some kind of magic bonus we are not seeing on this particular battle axe?

Badger1017

[ironsplitter]

Same for me. With all extensions off, the Off-Hand status does not remove the ability modifier from the damage on all weapons. And Two Weapon Fighting Style is NOT toggled. From my tests:
If weapon has no properties: removes damage bonus
If weapon has volatile, two handed, ranged: removed damage bonus
Otherwise: NO

I see on the vide that Moon Wizard posted he is using daggers, but that definitely does not work for me.

[Moon Wizard]

@delgondahntelius,
It was my special "test" battle axe that had more than one die.

@ironsplitter,
Please disable all extensions before testing. There has already been at least one extension identified which replaces some of the scripts, so the changes don't get picked up.

Regards,
JPG

[ironsplitter]

Hi MoonWizard,

All extensions are off except for a decal. I'm on Fantasy Grounds Classic btw.

There must be other things going on, because it works for SOME characters. It looks like if I add a dagger to a character that never had a dagger in their inventory before, then make the dagger off-hand, it works as expected. However, the off-hand effect doesn't work on daggers for characters that already had them. For those characters, if I remove the dagger from the inventory and add them back on it still doesn't work.

I don't know, probably a coincidence, but noting it anyway.

Thanks

[Naurthoron]

Same issue, brand new rogue character, no extension loaded at all, dagger offhand and two weapon fighting style disabled: ability damage modifier is still applied to offhand when it should not.