Complete Roslof module, Missing Item

[celestian]

If you find errors, please report them specifically so they can be adjusted.

Will do. I just finished up doing my AD&D plugin for ROS1 so as I expand to the ROS2-6 I'll post anything I find here if thats ok?

As for "wights on a level 1-3 dungeon", that is a story (author) thing, not a development issue.

Yeah, bit harsh IMO but Imma try and run it with it in and see how it goes.

[Talyn]

If it's something like a typo or an obvious error, I certainly fix it in my DLC. I'm probably the only one who does though. But this case of what sounds like a 1E::5E conversion that didn't ship with 5E monster stats (so... what exactly was "converted" then?) no, I wouldn't take it upon myself to "fix" it. I usually take that up in an email conversation with the author, if they'll bother to talk about it.

[Trenloe]

If it's something like a typo or an obvious error, I certainly fix it in my DLC. I'm probably the only one who does though.

You're not the only one. You'll frequently see conversion notes in FG products where the developer lists what they change from the base product, and this often includes fixing of errors.

[celestian]

If it's something like a typo or an obvious error, I certainly fix it in my DLC. I'm probably the only one who does though. But this case of what sounds like a 1E::5E conversion that didn't ship with 5E monster stats (so... what exactly was "converted" then?) no, I wouldn't take it upon myself to "fix" it. I usually take that up in an email conversation with the author, if they'll bother to talk about it.

Well, my original "missing" request was just plain missing. Wasn't a 5e/AD&D issue. The conversations later did bring up that but I'm not expecting Rob or Scott to go back and re-work the module to work with a official AD&D Ruleset since there isn't one Right now I'm ok with just going through and replicating the encounters/npc/loot for AD&D using my ruleset. Once done I do plan to offer the "plugin" module to Scott tho I dunno what he'll do with it. I'm only doing it for my own game use.

[Myrdin Potter]

03 16 room 11 - greater cyclops is missing the spear in description. Regular cyclops, not "greater".

Parcel has the helm as a ring and description says ring when you read it.

In general, all the monsters link to SRD only in the whole module even if the MM is open, so i am constantly swapping out tokens.

[rob2e]

C 18 room 12 - greater cyclops is missing the spear in description. Regular cyclops, not "greater".

Parcel has the helm as a ring and description says ring when you read it.

In general, all the monsters link to SRD only in the whole module even if the MM is open, so i am constantly swapping out tokens.

There is no C18 but I looked at every Room 12 and there's no mention of Cyclops. Can you screen shot that?

[Myrdin Potter]

03.16 room 11., sorry, typing this while DMing.

[rob2e]

c.16 room 11., sorry, typing this while DMing.

How dare you! I am answering this post while playing in a game with Doug Davison. HA! I'll check it.

Edit. You meant 3.16 rather than C.16 obviously. Error corrected and submitted.

[Myrdin Potter]

03.18 room 12.

You should add "corrupted" to the name of the creature in the encounter to populate the CT and for token name on the map.

[celestian]

There is no C18 but I looked at every Room 12 and there's no mention of Cyclops. Can you screen shot that?

I think he means Room 11 in ROS3. Looks like the cyclops uses a rock and not a spear.

edit: Not to be left out, I am playing right now, HAH!